Sitio web en Español:

Welcome to McGuire, Pelaez, Bennett & Belcastro, P.C.

Hablamos Español.

Para ver este sitio web en español, haga clic aquí.

McGuire, Pelaez, Bennett & Belcastro is a full-service law firm, with a special emphasis on handling criminal and traffic cases, personal injury matters, matrimonial and family court cases, as well as real estate and landlord-tenant matters, including foreclosure defense and post-foreclosure eviction defense, in Central Islip, Riverhead, and throughout Suffolk County on Long Island. In addition, our Suffolk County law office has handled personal injury cases including motor vehicle accident claims, slip and falls, and construction accidents. Languages spoken are English and Spanish.

When you face an important legal matter, experience counts.

Retired Judge – Former Prosecutors

Christopher McGuire and Mary Peláez are former Suffolk County prosecutors. Mr. Mcguire spent 12 years on the bench as a criminal court judge. Combined, they have 30 years of experience in private practice.

Watch Our Firm Video

Practice Areas

Criminal & Traffic Cases

Matrimonial & Family Court

Personal Injury

Landlord/Tenant Disputes

Real Estate Closings

School Discipline

Criminal Law Attorneys

Serving Central Islip and Riverhead in Suffolk County, Long Island

If you have been arrested and charged with a crime in Long Island, you need experienced representation to protect your legal rights.

Our Central Islip and Riverhead criminal law attorneys have been handling criminal cases for more than 20 years. We have a team of former prosecutors who speak English and Spanish, and have successfully handled thousands of misdemeanors and felonies, including assault, larceny, drug charges, driving while intoxicated (DWI / DWAI), criminal contempt, domestic violence, manslaughter, Aggravated Unlicensed (VTL 511), and other charges.

Serving Central Islip and Riverhead in Suffolk County, Long Island

When a relationship fails, it is hard enough to manage your emotions. It is even harder to manage your household. Our attorneys are sensitive to your needs and experienced in handling your legal matters.

Serving Central Islip and Riverhead in Suffolk County, Long Island

If you have been injured in an car accident, a construction site accident, a slip-and-fall accident, or an on-the-job accident, our accident attorneys have more than fifty years of expertise in handling these kinds of cases for the Suffolk County areas.

Serving Central Islip and Riverhead in Suffolk County, Long Island

If you are a landlord and you want to evict your tenant, or if you are a tenant who has a landlord who is violating the terms of your lease agreement or your right to live in suitable living conditions, our Long Island attorneys have more than fifteen years experience and have handled thousands of landlord-tenant matters.

Serving Central Islip and Riverhead in Suffolk County, Long Island

We understand that selling and buying a home, condominium, or cooperative is a stressful experience. Our goal is to use our more than ten years of experience in handling real estate matters to make your experience as simple and easy as possible while protecting your legal rights.

Serving Central Islip and Riverhead in Suffolk County, Long Island

The risk of suspension, expulsion, or other disciplinary measures can have a substantial impact on both a child’s education and their future success as independent adults. And whenever your child faces out-of-school suspension of more than five days, or another similarly severe punishment such as expulsion, you are entitled to an administrative hearing.

Reviews

4.8

See all reviews Write a review

Doug E.

1727367733

5 stars. Incredibly effective, efficient and professional. I could not recommend more highly!

Karolayn Coronel

1727180508

They are the best in their work, I highly recommend them.

fransisco martinez

1725376866

Los mejores en su trabajo

Rodrigo Zelayandia

1725370806

Ellos son los mejores abogados de long islan y lo mejor de todo es que hablan Español se merecen las 5 estrellas buena atencion

Lorenzo Thompson

1723666271

I got a speeding ticket, reckless driving and , they do a good job making it disappear I would recommend them to anyone

Alex Calderon

1723300134

Thank you for everything everyone at the law firm. Everyone was very helpful and kind especially the secretary. Thank you

Ann Marie O’Neil

1722811927

Tim and Karen were patient and kind throughout our ordeal of evicting our tenants.Would definitely recommend them.

Alex Lituma

1722454294

My experience working with this firm was superb! The associates here were all knowledgable , professional, patient and persistent with my case. I want to especially single out and thank two individuals who I worked closely with Jhoselyn and Bill. Their service was outstanding and their team work was unmatched. They both helped me resolve my case in a effiecent and effortless manner. If I ever am in need of legal services again I will return especially for the reason of working with those two! Thank you again to Mcguire, pelaez, bennett, and belcastro and all associates for your service!

John Wells

1722284653

Great staff, great lawyers, great pricing!

daivon campbell

1721746543

Mr Mcguire was very helpful with my case and I would recommend him for others…in my opinion he’s Better than Jayoma.

Johaira Martinez

1721744351

Great service ,great Lawyer ,they listen and they fight for you. The best experience that I’ve ever had with a lawyer and his team they are really professional and understanding and they will work with you and for you. I truly recommend them. these are the type of lawyers and team that you need in your team to fight for you. Thank u guys so much god bless 🙏🏽 (the winning team)

George Frontino

1721711534

Mr. Belcastro was incredibly helpful with my legal issues. He was there for me through every step of the process, kept me informed, and did not stop fighting until we reached a desirable outcome. His professionalism and knowledge continually demonstrated his dedication to his clients and his passion for his craft as an attorney.If you or someone you know is in need of legal services, I can, with one hundred percent faith, recommend Mr. Belcastro.

jose rivera

1721151138

Excellent Work and always providing the best results when it comes to traffic violationsHelped from 8Point violations into just a lower fine with no points

Stephanie Hovorka

1720277377

What could I say that hasn't been said already about Mr.McGuire? He was very prompt with responding to my initial inquiry and very confident my case could be handled. He was extremely kind, reasonable and above all easy to speak to. The office staff was very kind and welcoming. My experience was great and that's why I have used him again and again. Thank you for everything!!

Daniel Montenegro

1719950369

Amazing attorneys, they helped me a lot to win my case. Recommend 100%

Roque Franco

1719170519

Incredible and profecional. Can't ask for moreHighly recommend 👌

Jorge Ramos

1719069998

Mr. Bennett and his law firm has helped me in traffic cases. Thank you, recommend 100%

Anqel X

1719067276

Great

Larry Wasek

1718194687

Gustavo Vásquez

1717422645

This law firm did a really good job. They were really helpful. Very profesional place.

Kevin Mancia Escobar

1716566947

Everyone was very helpful. They helped me ger my traffic ticket into a parking ticket with no points. I will continue to come here for whatever it is. Truly the best.

John Wells

1716565910

My case was handled very well, the receptionist is great

Kleber Guaillas

1716472765

I am very pleased with the service here. I will continue coming back for more help. The ladies in the front were the best!

Kyle Jermyn

1715704278

McGuire and his team were very professional and on top of my cases. I recommend this law firm 100%

Jaimeson Graham

1715692627

Highly Professional and caring firm that caters to their clients. The office manager, Daslin, takes care of every detail along with the rest of the amazing staff. Extremely organized and willing to work with anyone!

Venomous_SpiderX

1714765184

They were really good and thorough and helped me fight and win my case. I would recommend them 100+%

Richard Caggiano

1714578733

Yeah I'm going to recommend a lawyer for anything, always get a lawyer , this place is awesome no points and just a fine worth the money remember people don't work for free and points or conviction costs way more

Edgar Pereira

1714087080

McGuire, Peláez, Bennett & Belcastro, P.C is the third time they have help me with tickets and lic suspension I recently had tickets, they are all dismissed my lic is clean because of there awesome work lawyers and all the staff are so helpful always available to answer my questions

Reginald Muhammad

1713918494

I have been with this firm for a couple years they have represented me now for several traffic violations/infractions. impeccable professionalism and service, and the results of the case were reduced or dismiss. I would like to show a special appreciation to the staff, from the paralegals to the interns to they are diligent, prepared and concise especially Jasmine the receptionist she welcomes the clients with open arms.

Salvatore Maggio

1713884174

This staff is amazing! Stayed on top of my case at all times! Always kept me posted! Very professional! And had my speeding ticket knocked down to a parking ticket. Highly recommend this office!

Mark Goode

1713817315

Highly recommend! Professional, easy, quick and effective.

James Closs

1713462068

I made the right decision going there. They are very professional, nice and knowledgeable. I recommend if you need a good lawyer to go there.

Laura Gray

1713454918

Attentive, responsive, thorough, knowledgeable, EFFECTIVE!

Waberte Ati

1712867408

Today, I had the pleasure of being represented by Timothy V. Sorell, Esq, of McGuire, Pelaez, Bennett & Belcastro, P.C., in court, and I couldn’t be more satisfied with the outcome. From the moment I met Mr. Sorell, his kindness and patience stood out. He was not only empathetic to my situation but also extremely diligent in his approach to my case.Mr. Sorell’s expertise was evident throughout the entire process. He was well-prepared, articulate, and persuasive in court. His dedication to my case was unwavering, and it was clear that he put a significant amount of effort into ensuring that we had the best possible chance of success.I would also like to extend my gratitude to the entire team at McGuire, Pelaez, Bennett & Belcastro, P.C. for their support and collaboration. Their professionalism and commitment were instrumental in achieving a favorable outcome.I am grateful for Mr. Sorell’s representation and the collective effort of the law office. I would highly recommend their services to anyone in need of legal assistance. Thank you for your exceptional service and for securing a favorable outcome in my case.

genesis freire

1712327509

This law firm is the best. I was charged with a petit larceny and could have gotten q criminal record. Luigi got the case discussed. Thank you.

Scott Trapani

1712086442

Brett has been a rockstar for us. Unfortunately we have had a couple of issues with my youngest, the last one being a speeding ticket. Brett handled it professionally for us, saving us the aggravation of travel for a court appearance. He was able to get the points penalty removed and just had to pay a fine that was manageable. Well worth it vs the headache of what our insurance would have been like! If I am in this situation again, I know who my family will be turning to.

New York Glass and Storefronts

1711986807

Amazing attorneys, very helpful.

Michael Cotoia

1711811136

Absolutely great experience! Was recommended through a friend, came in as a first time client, everyone was extremely nice, helpful, and professional throughout the whole process, was told not to worry it would be taken care of… couple months later I get a call and the tickets cleared with the exact results I was looking to get!! Would very highly recommend Chris Mcguire and this firm!! Thank you guys again!

Morgan Orlick

1711726179

This place is awesome. You need to go to them for all your traffic needs. They helped me get a speeding down to a parking ticket. I will use them for all my future traffic tickets for now on.

Jayne Furia

1711289355

Always helpful for the tickets I’ve had, came in on a Sunday when it was closed and took on my case. Very nice lawyer (Chris) who’s respectful and great at what he does.

Michael Chiaramonte

1711114991

Super professional and helped me with my traffic ticket. Highly recommended for any issue. Thank you!

Dominic Piccolo

1711114725

Everyone in this law firm was outstanding. Everyone was so helpful and kind. The lady at the front desk was phenomenal. They made everything easy and simple. I will continue to come back to them if needed in the future.

Jayovani

1711058090

Got me no points when I was stopped apparently going 85 in a 50 by state police. I recommend Mr. McGuire for traffic court for sure.

Christine Jorge

1710953278

I recently had the pleasure of working with Chris McGuire, and I can confidently say that he exceeded all expectations. From the moment I set up a consultation with him, I was impressed by his attentiveness and genuine concern for my situation. Chris took the time to listen to all of my concerns and made me feel truly heard, which immediately put me at ease.Throughout our discussions, Chris demonstrated a remarkable level of honesty and transparency. He didn't sugarcoat anything; instead, he provided me with a thorough understanding of all possible outcomes, ensuring that I was well-informed every step of the way.I am incredibly pleased with how everything turned out, and I credit Chris for his dedication and expertise. He exemplifies what every attorney should strive to be – compassionate, knowledgeable, and committed to achieving the best possible outcome for their clients.Without hesitation, I would turn to Chris McGuire and his staff for any future legal needs. I wholeheartedly recommend their services to anyone in search of exceptional legal representation. Thank you, Chris, for your outstanding work

Linsay T

1710419681

They were absolutely great! My insurance didn't go through to the DMV properly so I got pulled over & the cop was a jerk. Wrote me a bunch of unnecessary tickets. I was really struggling financially as well & couldn't miss work over this, so they were so kind to work out an arrangement with me. Very thankful for this group of lawyers

Jose Sepulveda

1710361858

Marlene Pessoa

1710273650

Mr. McGuire was extremely honest with the consultation and that was well appreciated. I felt comfortable and would recommend them to anyone who would benefit from their services.

Cesar Garcia

1710261013

Chris is an excellent lawyer. He is very kind and helpful. He helped me with my son’s traffic case. I would recommend him a million times and more.

Next Reviews

24/7/365 Emergency Hotline: 631-348-1702

24/7/365 Emergency Hotline: 631-348-1702

Welcome to McGuire, Pelaez, Bennett & Belcastro, P.C.